• NEW! Gift
  • WATCH
  • SERIES
  • ESSAYS
  • INTERVIEWS
    • Spotlight
    • NYC Dispatch
    • Festivals
    • Archive
  • ABOUT FLMTQ
Menu

 FILMATIQUE

Street Address
City, State, Zip
Phone Number

Your Custom Text Here

 FILMATIQUE

  • NEW! Gift
  • WATCH
  • SERIES
  • ESSAYS
  • INTERVIEWS
  • JOURNAL
    • Spotlight
    • NYC Dispatch
    • Festivals
    • Archive
  • ABOUT FLMTQ

A Political and Personal Voyage through Modern-day Ukraine in Vitaly Mansky's Close Relations

November 28, 2017 Melinda Prisco
   Close Relations  , Vitaly Mansky (2016)

Close Relations, Vitaly Mansky (2016)

 

Vitaly Mansky’s personal documentation in Rodnye (Close Relations) follows a subjective turn in documentary cinema, according to which this film diary consists of interviews between his family members in Ukraine, reflecting upon the continuing Ukraine-Russia conflict, and several questions around national identity.  Mansky explores these views during a time period from May 2014 to May 2015.  He visits his relatives in Lviv, Odessa, and Sevastopol in the annexed Crimea.  He also makes a trip to Donetsk-region where the conflict between Russia and Ukraine still exists.

 

Mansky includes his own voice as the narrator of happenings.  In this sense, his gaze is bound to the camera's perspective, so the film has a sort of autobiographical pact around the issues Mansky is depicting.  Mansky is showing us a historical world through his own subjectivity, since his active enunciation filters our perception of the presented events.  This subjective presence involves a certain double movement: firstly inwards, concerning his identity and personality, and secondly outwards, describing the historical context, in which his relatives are currently living.

 

Mansky's mother, grandfather and aunts all reflect on their situation from various perspectives.  This perspectivization gives the documentary its charm, since their notions are in relation to all these political and social changes that have happened in Ukraine.  Mansky seems to think that despite the fact that the interviewees express their individuality, they also reveal their commonality somehow, although they seem to be quite opposite of each other.

 
   Close Relations  , Vitaly Mansky (2016)

Close Relations, Vitaly Mansky (2016)

 

Mansky's observational style echoes these reflections, depicting the cities of Lviv, Odessa and Sevastopol as lived spaces, and using his own personal history in order to represent a kind of collective experience between his family members.  He combines his reflective attitude towards everyday street scenes with a personal commentary that in some scenes echoes a subjective reading of the images.  In his own way, Mansky creates a portrait of the life in several cities from a collective and autobiographical perspective at the same time. 

 

Beyond such explicit references, Mansky creates a series of dialogues between the political situation in Ukraine and Russia.  One of the most revealing sequences of the narrative is a scene wherein three of his aunts express and talk about politics via Skype and assert their conflicting opinions.  Mansky pays particular attention to the way his relatives behave with their ideological beliefs.  The decision to observe and emphasize this kind of behavior at length lead to situations in which one of the aunts neglects the presence of the other one. 

 

In Mansky's film, the role of city-images is heightened, whether their motivation is connected with symbolic or aesthetic grounds, or whether by extension of temporal narrative challenge.  The mise-en-scène of the narration becomes a documentation of certain, mostly Ukrainian places and spaces with an idea of representing subjective experiences in the middle of this landscape.  The importance of the landscape is a crucial point since landscapes contain the ability to carry feeling with or without any human drama to precipitate it.  The dramatic focus of the narrative lies in the confrontation between the audience and the landscape.  This might look like a standard device in filmmaking, filling the spectator with undefined expectation, and connecting the narrative with filmmaker's personal thinking.

 
   Close Relations  , Vitaly Mansky (2016)

Close Relations, Vitaly Mansky (2016)

 

The audience experiences this and feels the subjectivity of the views in both observational and performative dimensions— acquiring a way of being-in-there.  The audience can also use its own subjectivity to appreciate, appropriate and extend the meaning of Mansky's filmic views to the point of turning the documentary into a symbolic demonstration of Ukraine's fate in the middle of this contemporary historical situation.

 

Close Relations is a cinematic mapping of Mansky's voyage through modern-day Ukraine that not only shows where he has been but also how he felt there.  This forms a performative aura around the narrative, consisting of political, historical, social and individual testimonies that he shares with close intimacy.  Maybe the whole enterprise works as a sketchbook of ideas around the filmmaker's subjectivity, around his emotional reactions and motifs.  Here, the cinematic language is heavily labelled by subjectivity, viewpoints that developed through choices.  The deployments and connections between memory and history allow us to consider Mansky's attempt to order and re-order our conceptual understanding of the events in Ukraine's near-history.  In a broader compass, our relation to history becomes a meditative practice that gives observational possibilities to comprehend and re-interpret Mansky's visions and views.

 

Close Relations documents the places where Mansky has been and the things that have caught his attention there.  Mansky reveals that since he no longer lives in Russia, he does not have to consider events there as his own personal tragedy.  Mansky's approach reminds us about the documentary's ability to focus on the encounters between a certain reality, the filmic apparatus, and the filmmaker.  The subjective vision creates an aura of detached but personal notes with honesty.  In conclusion, Close Relations offers a personal view from the street-level that becomes a vivid experience of engaged and shared observation, in which Vitaly Mansky embraces and enlarges the common markers of subjectivity.  A political diary is created, with its own aesthetics and form of fragmentary narration focusing on the atmospheric situation in contemporary Ukraine.

 
WATCH CLOSE RELATIONS
 

//

 

 

Essay by Dr. Jarmo Valkola
Professor at Baltic Film and Media School
Tallinn University,

Guest Curator, Filmatique

← The Miscreants and Transnational Moroccan CinemaThe Road is Cold and Dark Ahead: The Days That Confused and Neoliberalization in Estonia →

Related articles / essays

Featured
The Fire is About to Start: History and Memory in Independência
In Bed with Contemporary French Cinema: Victoria
Swagger and New Suburban Cinema
El Tiempo Nublado: The Ethics of Documentary Filmmaking as Activism
Death, Desolation, and Dystopia in El Limpiador (The Cleaner)
Girimunho: Life Imagined in the Backlands of Minas Gerais
Challat of Tunis: Sexism, Lies and Computer Games in Tunisia
Coming Forth by Day, or How Condensed Time and Space Reveal the Revolution
Chaos by Design: Harag W'Marag / Chaos, Disorder
The Miscreants and Transnational Moroccan Cinema
A Political and Personal Voyage through Modern-day Ukraine in Vitaly Mansky's Close Relations
The Road is Cold and Dark Ahead: The Days That Confused and Neoliberalization in Estonia
The Labyrinths of Narration: Chaos and Mayhem at the Latvian Collective Farm in Dawn
Gaps in Pride and Communication in the Lives of Three Norwegian Women
Dreaming Around the Archive in Il Solengo
Home is a Hard Place to Film: Eleonora Danco's Allegorical Documentary N-Capace
Evocative Beauty and the Puzzle of Identity in Opera Prima Italiana
The State of Italian Cinema: Five Young Auteurs
Underground Fragrance: Soil and Subsoil in Modern-Day China
Spotlight on Brazil: Four Films Looking for a Country
Gentle and Our Love Story: Deconstructing the Heteronormative Gaze
Keep Smiling & Georgia's Second New Wave of Female Filmmakers
Love, Adventure and Nationhood in the Everyday
Nabat: Female Fortitude & Survival in Azerbaijan
Temporality and Borders in True Noon
Heavenly Nomadic & Natural-Mystical Traditions of Kyrgyz Cinema
With the Eyes of Others: Reza Mirkarimi's Today in Perspective
Corn Island, Tarkovsky & The Legacy of 'Slow Cinema'
The Genesis and Urgency of Silvered Water: Syria Self Portrait
Xavier Dolan & the Queer Palm: Cinema as Art vs. Artifact
CONTACT

© 2018 Filmatique